The next edition of the explosive “Twitter Files” on Friday revealed federal agencies were in contact with Twitter in the run-up to the 2020 election while being directly involved censoring content and former President Donald Trump.
Journalist Matt Taibbi posted the thread over three hours in which each snippet contained valuable information on the inner workings of the platforms’ censorship campaign.
The information confirmed long-held suspicions about what Twitter was doing, including the revelation that executives went against their own policies to censor Trump.
The Twitter files appear to focus on the lead-up to the platform’s decision to permanently ban the President on January 8, 2021, in the wake of the U.S. Capitol riot.
The files also show that Twitter had special Slack channels to monitor Trump’s tweets and to make decisions to add warning labels or censor him completely.
Nick Pickles, the then Twitter Policy Director, seemed to admit the platform was meeting officials from the FBI and DHS regarding some actions taken against Trump.
In an internal message, Yoel Roth, then-Twitter Global Head for Trust & Safety, confirmed he was meeting with the FBI, DHS, and Director of National Intelligence about election security and about the Hunter Biden laptop story.
20. This post about the Hunter Biden laptop situation shows that Roth not only met weekly with the FBI and DHS, but with the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (DNI): pic.twitter.com/s5IiUjQqIY
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 9, 2022
Taibbi added that Roth appeared to admit that he had “weekly confabs with federal law enforcement.”
23. Some of Roth’s later Slacks indicate his weekly confabs with federal law enforcement involved separate meetings. Here, he ghosts the FBI and DHS, respectively, to go first to an “Aspen Institute thing,” then take a call with Apple. pic.twitter.com/i771hD8aCD
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 9, 2022
Taibbi also showed tweets the FBI flagged for Twitter around election security:
The FBI's second report concerned this tweet by @JohnBasham: pic.twitter.com/8J8j5GlUVx
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
According to screenshots, employees looked to censor Trump on multiple occasions but were rebuffed because the information was accurate.
RELATED: Ex-Intelligence Officials Who Claimed Hunter Biden Laptop Was ‘Russian Disinfo’ Remain SILENT
Roth appeared to be pleased with the platform’s actions against Trump, the screenshots revealed.
35. In another example, Twitter employees prepare to slap a “mail-in voting is safe” warning label on a Trump tweet about a postal screwup in Ohio, before realizing “the events took place,” which meant the tweet was “factually accurate”: pic.twitter.com/4r6nJ3JDmY
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
"VERY WELL DONE ON SPEED": the group is pleased the Trump tweet is dealt with quickly pic.twitter.com/WMyQjbWqNW
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
Aside from efforts to censor Trump, other internal documents revealed Twitter also targeted conservative actor James Woods for posting a screenshot of a Trump tweet. Woods was not hit with a violation for the tweet, although the team vowed they would hit hard in the future for a different violation.
38. After Woods angrily quote-tweeted about Trump’s warning label, Twitter staff – in a preview of what ended up happening after J6 – despaired of a reason for action, but resolved to “hit him hard on future vio.” pic.twitter.com/dusFylxAXS
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
Meanwhile, tweets from the political Left, clearly in violation of the platform’s policies, were largely left alone because Twitter officials decided they would not take action against pro-Biden tweets.
42. “THAT’S UNDERSTANDABLE”: Even the hashtag #StealOurVotes – referencing a theory that a combo of Amy Coney Barrett and Trump will steal the election – is approved by Twitter brass, because it’s “understandable” and a “reference to… a US Supreme Court decision.” pic.twitter.com/6BjJhjypD2
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
44. Later in November 2020, Roth asked if staff had a “debunk moment” on the “SCYTL/Smartmantic vote-counting” stories, which his DHS contacts told him were a combination of “about 47” conspiracy theories: pic.twitter.com/QiYGlZE202
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
Taibbi also revealed how the team took additional measures to reduce the visibility of many of Trump’s tweets in early December 2020.
48. The significance is that it shows that Twitter, in 2020 at least, was deploying a vast range of visible and invisible tools to rein in Trump’s engagement, long before J6. The ban will come after other avenues are exhausted
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
“There is no way to follow the frenzied exchanges among Twitter personnel from between January 6th and 8th without knowing the basics of the company’s vast lexicon of acronyms and Orwellian unwords,” Taibbi wrote.
“This is all necessary background to J6. Before the riots, the company was engaged in an inherently insane/impossible project, trying to create an ever-expanding, ostensibly rational set of rules to regulate every conceivable speech situation that might arise between humans.”
“This project was preposterous yet its leaders were unable to see this, having become infected with groupthink, coming to believe – sincerely – that it was Twitter’s responsibility to control, as much as possible, what people could talk about, how often, and with whom,” he continued.
“When panic first breaks out on J6, there’s a fair share of WTF-type posts, mixed in with frantic calls for Twitter to start deploying its full arsenal of moderation tools.”
This project was preposterous yet its leaders were unable to see this, having become infected with groupthing, coming to believe – sincerely – that it was Twitter's responsibility to control, as much as possible, what people could talk about, how often, and with whom.
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
60. Minutes later, Roth executed the historic act of “bouncing” Trump, i.e. putting him in timeout. “I hope you… are appropriately CorpSec’d,” says a colleague. pic.twitter.com/KDr6ZFle8h
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
61. The first company-wide email from Gadde on January 6th announced that 3 Trump tweets had been bounced, but more importantly signaled a determination to use legit “violations” as a guide for any possible permanent suspension: pic.twitter.com/p6WmbS2MsA
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022
63. A few last notes about January 6th. Roth at one point looked and found Trump had a slew of duplicate bot applications: pic.twitter.com/7dvgQS3Tss
— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) December 10, 2022